Fintech Perspectives

Integrated Stock Broking and Digital Current Accounts

Why European brokerage firms should launch integrated digital current accounts: the defensive, customer-experience and economic case.

It is time for European stock brokerage firms to embrace the world of Challenger banking models. There have been tentative steps taken in the US by Robinhood which resulted later in a shelved checking account foray, in Europe both Revolut and Vivid Money have taken robust steps towards an integrated current and stockbroking account. But I want to explore this topic from the point of view of brokerage firms as this industry vertical has for far too long operated in a silo with innovations limited to UX/UI interfaces and discount brokerage models.

Here’s some industry context to begin with:

We live in times where financial services are evolving in a way where customer relationships and user experience are becoming central to the business model. While core product expertise remains important, firms that holistically pursue a customer engagement strategy, unconstrained by product silos will emerge winners. I came across this rather neat example in a McKinsey article ( Feb 2019) on the Music business where they highlighted how the music industry used to traditionally bundles various songs from a single artist in a single record album. When a customer buys the album, they end up buying the “good” songs with the “not so interesting” songs. What has happened subsequently is the “unbundling” of the Music industry where the likes of iTunes & Spotify made it possible for customers to select and buy specific songs. Spotify of course offers music catalogs personalized to customer’s music listening habits, using analytics to create a truly personalized offering. This is in many ways a return to “bundling”, but this times the bundles are created based around an individual customer’s choices (so “personalized bundling”).

I believe the financial services industry is also undergoing a similar change. Traditionally large multinational and even large domestic banks have provided universal banking services to individuals and businesses. -Global banks such as JP Morgan Chase, Citibank, Bank of America, HSBC have historically provided end-to-end services using a "category-killer approach”. Customers used to bank with one large institution and often took most of their banking transactions whether it was checking accounts (aka current accounts on this side of the pond), credit cards, or mortgages (the "bundled approach"). We then had the emergence of specialist firms that launched in specific categories (“unbundling of financial services”) and attacked profit pools of the big global banks for example Capital One in Credit cards and Charles Schwab in Brokerage. We now have the likes of Revolut, Monzo, N26 emerging as fintechs who have built a strong customer franchise in monoline product categories, current accounts, and cards initially, but are now surely and slowly evolving into financial marketplaces. They are doing this by listening carefully to their online communities of customers, getting their customers to tell them what needs to be built next and building partnerships with providers (personalized bundling) to architect a customer-experience first-led product stack.

There are some important lessons here for the stock brokerage industry in Europe which has seen limited innovation in recent times. In the US, Charles Schwab has evolved into a truly effective and profitable brokerage firm with a large banking business driving customer growth and profitability. Consider these facts,

  • The Charles Schwab Corporation is a leading provider of financial services, with 31 million active brokerage accounts and 1.6 million banking accounts, and $7 trillion managed in client assets. It was founded in 1971.
  • Formed a Bank in 2003 which offers checking accounts, loans, etc. In 2009, revenue from Banking was 29% of the total Charles Schwab Group revenue…
  • Overall Revenue for Charles Schwab Group was $2.6 Billion Qtr ended June 2019. That for the Banking subsidiary was $1.7 Billion – more than 50% came from Banking !!

If one were to extend the argument to the European stock brokerage industry, there are three great arguments for creating an integrated digital bank account and stock brokerage product stack.

The “defensive play” argument

Growing competition from discount brokerages

Most European countries are facing a negative or a very low-interest rate environment. Retail banking customers earn very low or nil returns on deposits. Low-cost discount brokerages (FreeTrade, De Giro, etc) are growing across EU markets, allowing customers access to simple investment products- equities, ETFs, and Mutual funds, which offer better returns than bank deposits

Wealth Management- baseline proposition

Fintechs in the US & Europe are now considering wealth management as a baseline proposition alongside current accounts, to grow customer "stickiness" and fee-based revenue

To defend an existing market position and to maintain relevance with customers seeking returns on surplus funds, brokerage accounts integrated with current accounts may soon become the "new normal"- existing brokerage firms should thus consider launching a simple e-money based digital current account

The “customer” experience argument

Remove friction from payments

Integrated current accounts will make incoming payments as well as outgoing payments frictionless. IBANs allocated to current accounts will allow salary deposits, reducing the need for card-based top-ups ( saving anywhere between 40-80 bps in merchant service charges). Integration with Faster payments / SEPA credits / SWIFT will make outgoing payments faster

Superior Economics

There is also an argument to be made based on Economics where a subscription-based integrated account, combining basic banking and stock brokerage services could fetch a higher premium from customers, especially mass affluent customers.

For Stock brokerage firms that have never stepped in banking services, let alone digital banking, constructing a flexible go-to-market model for launching integrated banking services will require careful considerations. There are multiple choices involved across program definition (product, pricing, processes), local regulatory and scheme licensing options, card processing platforms, IBAN and agency banking solutions platforms, etc. Digital bank accounts are not inherently “unit economics positive” and one of the important considerations in architecting an integrated proposition is making sure that one achieves superior unit economics on the integrated proposition- in short, the whole must be greater than the sum of the parts.

With digital activity vastly increasing in a covid world, and consumers sitting on trillions of dollars of accumulated personal savings, waiting for a post-crisis opportunity to spend and invest, there is no better time to explore an integrated proposition combining banking and retail trading.