Fintech Perspectives

The Case for Retailers Embracing Self-Acquiring

The economics and a seven-step roadmap for large UK retailers bringing card acquiring in-house under a payment institution licence.

In recent weeks, high-profile payment system outages at major UK retailers like Greggs, Tesco, and Sainsbury's have underscored the critical need for robust and resilient payment systems. These incidents spotlight the importance of retailers taking direct control over their card payment processing, including obtaining regulatory licenses and direct scheme memberships, with traditional acquirers serving as third-party processors.

This model, known as Self-Acquiring, isn't just a reactive measure to these failures but a strategic move towards autonomy, innovation, and cost savings. Notable examples include retailers in France and Australia who have established self-acquiring operations and direct connectivity to domestic payment schemes and, in some cases, issuing banks, to manage transactions across all channels—online, in-store, and mobile.

The Case for Self-Acquiring

Retailers play a pivotal role in the payments ecosystem, investing in POS infrastructure and contributing to the revenue streams of acquirers, issuers, and payment schemes. Despite this significant role, payment processing is often viewed as a non-core operational concern. However, the landscape is changing. Regulatory changes, technological advancements, and market dynamics compel retailers to reassess their involvement in the payments value chain.

Payment institution licensing, for example, allows non-banks, including retailers, to acquire licenses for card processing and negotiate directly with payment schemes. This regulatory evolution, alongside the advent of programmable POS terminals capable of delivering value-added services, presents a compelling argument for retailers to adopt a self-acquiring model.

Economic Rationale and Strategic Implications

The economic benefits of self-acquiring are clear. By internalizing the acquiring function, Large Tier Retailers can capture the typical 0.03%-0.05% of gross margin on processing payments previously allocated to external merchant-acquirers, after allocating for scheme fees and interchange. In some cases where acquirers take revenue (indirectly) via float revenue, a self-acquiring model would eliminate float costs for the Retailer, as settlements for card purchases will be received on T+1 basis, directly from schemes.

The upfront costs of bringing card acquiring in-house can range from £3 million with an outsourced solution to £8 million if developed in-house, plus £0.5 million in annual software maintenance and payment security & scheme-related upgrade costs. By internalizing the gross margins through Self-Acquiring (potentially under an internal "payments business unit") and netting off the upfront investments and ongoing costs of managing an acquiring solution in-house, a Tier 1 Retailer processing between £6 billion to £10 billion in annual card payment volumes would benefit from net savings.

A Roadmap to Self-Acquiring

Adopting self-acquiring necessitates a detailed, multifaceted approach:

  1. Mapping Existing Costs — Retailers should start by evaluating current acquiring costs across sales channels and markets, especially for those operating on an international scale.
  2. Building Strategic Rationale — A compelling strategic rationale centered on cost savings, innovation, and revenue generation through value-added services and white labelling should be developed.
  3. Choosing the Right Go-to-Market Model — Retailers must select a go-to-market model that aligns with their corporate objectives and market conditions, which could range from establishing an independent merchant acquiring business to forming collaborations with banking partners.
  4. Building or Procuring the Platform — Decisions around whether to develop an in-house platform or procure an external solution must be made, including the acquisition of necessary software assets for onboarding and value-added services.
  5. Applying for Regulatory and Scheme Licenses — Necessary regulatory licenses for card processing must be secured along with direct memberships with payment schemes to ensure compliance and operational readiness.
  6. System Integration and Testing — The new acquiring solution needs to be integrated with existing POS systems, requiring detailed technical work, testing, and deployment. This includes decisions around implementing host-to-host connections or integrating existing terminals directly into the new acquiring host gateway, considering security, data protocols, and certification implications.
  7. Testing and Launch — A phased approach, beginning with comprehensive testing at a dedicated site followed by a beta phase at select retail locations, is recommended to identify, and rectify operational issues before a broader rollout.

This structured approach ensures a seamless transition to self-acquiring, enhancing operational efficiency, innovation, and control over the payments ecosystem.

Conclusion

The shift towards self-acquiring presents a strategic opportunity for Retailers to bolster operational efficiency, introduce innovative payment solutions, and exercise greater control over their payments ecosystem. Prompted by recent payment system failures, this transition underscores the need for retailers to reassess their payment processing strategies, leveraging the benefits of self-acquiring to navigate future challenges.